A very interesting line of thought. I can see your point. But then there has to be a panel and strict criteria on how to select such improved members. We have to remember we are all in a competitive environment. In that circumstance who can judge whom. For example I am not happy with the selection of prints/DPIs selected for external competitions. What you are saying can only happen where few people are not in a competitive position which is not possible. People come to a photographic club to do photography, not to help others. Therefore I don't think it is viable idea although it is a great idea.